|
|
|
||||||
|
|
|||||||
Quick links to products available in the Campaign for Genital Integrity . . .
|
Excerpts from
Female Genital Mutilation and the Responsibility of Reproductive Health Professionals
Nahid Toubia, M.D.
International Journal Gynecology & Obstetrics, 46, pp. 127-135, 1994
NOTE: This article focuses on female genital mutilation. NOHARMM believes the excerpts below are relevant and/or applicable to genital mutilation of either sex..
"The unnecessary
removal of a functioning body organ in the name of tradition, custom or any other
non-disease related cause should never be acceptable to the health profession. All
childhood circumcisions are violations of human rights and a breach of the fundamental
code of medical ethics."
"It is the moral
duty of educated professionals to protect the health and rights of those with little or no
social power to protect themselves."
"Today there are
reports of a variety of cosmetic labial operations performed at the request of women for
non-medical indications, usually because they or their partners think their labia are
ugly." [NOHARMM
comment: Some intact men are coerced into circumcision by their partners or other social
pressures.]
"The functional
anatomy of the female genitals is identical to that of male genitals."
"In contrast to the
number of studies and case reports on the physical complications of genital mutilations,
little scientific evidence is available on the sexual and psychological effects of the
practices."
"(M)any infibulated
women report a syndrome of genitally focused anxiety-depression
characterized by constant worry over the state of their genitals."
"(A)bility to
achieve orgasm varies, depending on the severity of the operation and the extent to which
social messages inhibiting sexual expression are internalized."
"The assumption that
all circumcised women have sexual problems or are unable to achieve orgasm has no
scientific evidence to support it." [NOHARMM comment: Conversely, the assumption that all
circumcised men are unaffected by their circumcisions has no scientific evidence
to support it.]
"For some girls and
women, the psychological impact can be extreme. For the majority of girls and women, the
psychological effects are more likely to be subtle, and buried beneath layers of denial,
mixed with resignation and acceptance of social norms. Understanding the psycho-social
balancing act which allows the child to overcome the trauma of circumcision, and the adult
woman to live with its consequences, is important to helping women overcome their
resistance to change."
"Parental consent
for a procedure that damages rather than preserves a childs health is ethically and
legally unacceptable."
"There are civil
laws governing the health profession
and ethical guidelines of health
professionals associations. Beyond passing such regulations, publicizing them
through doctors and nurses associations, as well as through the media to the
general public, is an important tool in eradicating the practice. Prescribed penalties for
breaking the regulations should be made explicit, and offenders must be shamed in public
and have their licenses revoked. Such action would send a strong message of condemnation
of the procedures from the highly respected professional health establishment to the
general public."
"The practice is
damaging to the physical and psychological health of girls, and is performed without true
consent. In many societies, health professionals have successfully opposed tribal ritual
and other customary bodily mutilations. Female genital mutilation should not be exempt
from such opposition."
"An active debate
should exist within the health profession and with other groups, including legal
specialists and grassroots womens organizations, to determine the appropriate
ethical stance and legal actions needed to combat the practice."
"From now on, the
question should never be whether the practice should be abolished or not, but how it can
be abolished sensitively and effectively, without hurting those who already suffer from
it."
Nahid Toubia, M.D. is a physician and surgeon from Sudan, and currently Associate Professor at Columbia University, School of Public Health, New York. She is director of the womens reproductive health organization RAINBO.
More Pages Related to Male & Female Circumcision |
Top of Page | Home | Updates | FAQ | Research |
Education
| Advocacy | Litigation | Search
| Ideas | For
Media | Videos
| Bookstore |
FactFinder
Your Rights | Attorneys for the Rights of the Child
| Video
Excerpt | Dads | FGC Experts | Position
Statement | Harm Form | Class Action
Last updated: 22 February, 2008
© 1998-2021 NOHARMM. All rights reserved. Questions, or problems
using this site? Webmaster